Lemon Squeezy's core offer is not its checkout — it is the merchant-of-record model behind it. As your MoR, it calculates, collects, and remits sales tax and VAT for you, runs fraud prevention with automated risk scoring, and charges no monthly fee: 5% + 50¢ per transaction, with custom volume pricing through sales and the caveat that some payments may carry additional fees. Around that core it wraps recurring billing (weekly, monthly, yearly, with trials, discounts, upgrades and downgrades), usage-based billing in several shapes (metered via a usage reporting API, per-seat, volume, graduated — combinable on one product), automatic license key issuance and deactivation, no-code checkout links and embeddable overlays, hosted storefronts, digital downloads over signed and throttled links, a self-service customer portal, and reporting on MRR, churn, trial conversion, refunds, and AOV. It accepts 21 payment methods including cards, ACH, Apple Pay, WeChat Pay, and AliPay, and supports PayPal subscriptions without a separate PayPal setup — it can even migrate your existing PayPal subscribers free. The four alternatives below are not four versions of the same thing: Paddle is the other merchant of record, Stripe is the full payments platform where you stay the merchant, Clerk is an authentication product whose billing add-on may be all the billing you need, and Shopify is the answer when what you sell stops being files and starts being a store.
Quick answer
Stay with Lemon Squeezy if you sell software or digital products and want tax handled for a flat 5% + 50¢ with no monthly fee. Choose Paddle if you want the same merchant-of-record model with B2B invoicing and dunning tooling, and you accept quote-based pricing. Choose Stripe if you want to own the customer relationship and the tax liability yourself in exchange for the deepest payments platform. Choose Clerk if your real need is authentication with plan gating inside your app, and paying 0.7% of billing volume through Stripe is acceptable. Choose Shopify if you are opening a store — physical goods, POS, multichannel — not just selling downloads.
What to look for
•Who is the merchant of record: this decides who owes the sales tax and VAT — the platform, or you.
•Fee structure: a flat 5% + 50¢, a custom quote, per-product platform pricing, 0.7% of volume on top of Stripe, or a store subscription.
•What you are selling: license keys and signed download links, usage-based billing depth, in-app plan gating, or inventory and POS.
•Migration: what happens to existing subscribers — for example, Lemon Squeezy offers free migration of PayPal subscriptions.
The direct rival: the other merchant of record here, with multi-product subscriptions (add-ons, multi-seat), a built-in customer portal, B2B invoicing, Paddle Retain for dunning, and ProfitWell Metrics free. Pricing is all-inclusive and transaction-based with no monthly fee, but there is no published fixed rate — it is custom and volume-based. Constraints from its listing: all items on a multi-product subscription must share one billing period, and products under $10 need bespoke pricing. Its listing's currency counts conflict ('more than 20' at checkout vs '29+ currencies and 17+ languages' in billing materials); we use the conservative figure.
The platform answer, with the model flipped: you are the merchant, you keep the customer relationship and the tax liability (tax automation is available as a product, not a transfer of liability). Depth is unmatched: hosted Checkout, Elements, no-code Payment Links, Billing for subscriptions, Metronome for usage-based billing, Invoicing, Connect for platforms and marketplaces, Terminal for in-person payments, across 135+ currencies and payment methods. Pricing is per-product and varies. Its scale figures ($1.9T platform volume in 2025, 99.999% historical uptime, 200M+ active subscriptions, +17.8% average cross-border lift) are company-reported.
Free Tier🛡️SOC 2SOC 2 (Security Audit)System and Organization Controls 2A SOC 2 report is an independent audit of a vendor's controls for security, availability, and confidentiality. The badge indicates the vendor has undergone that audit.
An authentication and user-management platform whose billing add-on puts subscription tables, portals, and plan gating inside your app; billing runs through Stripe and Clerk charges 0.7% of billing volume. Hobby is free up to 50,000 monthly retained users; Pro starts at $20/month billed annually; Business is $250/month. Badges lead with SOC 2, and API support is marked as available. Honest framing: Clerk is not a merchant of record — tax stays with you — so it fits when billing is simple plan gating inside an app that already needs auth.
The whole-store answer: storefront, POS, multichannel sales, and Shopify Payments in one back office, with the Sidekick AI assistant built in. Free trial (3 days free, then $1/month for 3 months); Basic from $29/month; card rates from 2.9% + 30¢; transaction fees may apply without Shopify Payments. API support is marked as available; no compliance badges are listed. Choose it when selling software has turned into running a shop; stay with a merchant of record when all you ship is downloads and licenses.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Lemon Squeezy charge?
There is no monthly fee. Lemon Squeezy charges 5% + 50¢ per transaction, with custom volume pricing available through sales; some payments may carry additional fees. Its email-marketing feature is billed separately and is free up to 500 subscribers.
What is the difference between Lemon Squeezy and Paddle?
Both are merchants of record that handle sales tax and VAT for you. Lemon Squeezy publishes a flat rate (5% + 50¢); Paddle's pricing is custom and volume-based, and it adds B2B invoicing and the Paddle Retain dunning toolkit. Paddle also requires all items on a multi-product subscription to share one billing period.
Is Stripe a merchant of record like Lemon Squeezy?
No. With Stripe you remain the merchant and keep the tax liability; Stripe offers tax automation as a product, but it does not become your reseller. That is the fundamental trade behind Stripe's deeper platform.
Can I sell subscriptions and license keys with these alternatives?
Lemon Squeezy issues and deactivates license keys automatically and supports recurring and usage-based billing. Paddle covers subscriptions including multi-seat; Clerk gates plans inside your app with billing through Stripe at 0.7% of volume; Shopify is built for store commerce rather than license delivery.